|
|
||||||||
NEUROREGULATION AND MOTILITY
Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Dysphagia Institute, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin; and Chaim Sheba Medical Center, Tel Hashomer, Israel
Submitted 8 December 2004 ; accepted in final form 30 August 2005
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
transsphincteric pressure; upper esophageal sphincter; dysphagia
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
For recording the pharyngo-UES intraluminal pressure phenomenon, we used a solid-state transducer assembly. Two three-site transducer probes with their pressure sensors 3 cm apart were secured side-by-side, so that the manometric recording sites were separated by 1.5 cm. The frequency response of these solid-state transducers was 20,000 Hz. The transducer assembly was passed transnasally and positioned such that, at rest, the two most proximal manometric sites were in the hypopharynx, the two middle sites were in the UES high-pressure zone, and the distal sites were in the proximal esophagus. The recording sites faced posteriorly. All pressure measurements were referenced to local atmospheric pressure. All pressure data were displayed on an 8-channel Sensormedics polygraph and concurrently recorded on a 16-channel Vetter FM tape recorder for subsequent analysis with a computerized digitization system.
The computer system for analyzing the manometric data consisted of a personal computer-compatible computer operating the system driving analog-to-digital (A/D) conversion hardware and software (DATAQ Instruments, Toledo, OH). The A/D program (CODAS) is a menu-driven capture-and-analysis package that allows for the asynchronous concurrent capture of up to 16 channels of data. The maximum sampling frequency of the system is 50 kHz, which exceeds the frequency requirements for sampling pharyngeal-UES pressure activity. The A/D conversion hardware and CODAS software allowed for capture and analysis of the six-channel pressure transducer signals at sampling frequencies higher than the limitations of the polygraph recording pens (30 Hz), as well as analysis of the captured manometric data in time scales unattainable in a conventional polygraph paper-and-pen recording.
To record bolus motion during swallowing, we studied the subjects concurrently by videofluoroscopy. The subject sat in a chair, positioned laterally to the face of the image intensifier. The subject was instructed to hold his head in a neutral position. Videofluoroscopic recordings were obtained at 90 keV with a 22.86-cm (9-inch) image intensifier mode and appropriate collimation so that a lateral image of the posterior mouth, pharynx, and pharyngoesophageal region was obtained. Fluoroscopic images were recorded on a super-VHS videocassette recorder (AG-1960 Proline, Panasonic, Tokyo, Japan) that recorded 60 fields/s. The manometric and fluoroscopic recordings were synchronized by means of a specially designed timer (Thalner Electronics, Ann Arbor, MI). The timer, video recorder, and polygraph were electrically connected. The timer generates two simultaneous signals: one provided a video-displayed time signal in hundredths of a second on the fluoroscopic images, and the other generated a 1-Hz, 5-V-amplitude timing pulse that was recorded on the chart paper used for manometric recording. For each swallow, the first pulse marked on the manometric recording paper was noted and logged, along with the elapsed tape count displayed on the videocassette recorder. The chart paper was run at a speed of 50 mm/s; thus each millimeter on the paper represented 20 ms. The timer signal also allowed synchronization of morphological events recorded on videofluoroscopic images, with the manometric events recorded on the FM tape recorder.
The computer analysis system used for analyzing the videofluoroscopic data consisted of a computerized system driving an A/D conversion board and program specifically designed for image capture and analysis. The image analysis-and-capture software (JAVA, Jandel Scientific, San Mateo, CA) allows capture of standard raster scan video images and morphological analysis of digitized image data. The digitized images were stored as computer files for any subsequent recall or analysis.
All subjects were studied during four swallows of each of the following: 1) a barium pellet (0.2-cm-diameter spherical pills) and 2) 5 ml of liquid barium and three dry swallows. Each barium pellet was swallowed without mastication, and no additional fluid, except the ambient saliva present during deglutition, was swallowed. For all swallows, we determined the velocity and acceleration of the barium pellet and the head and tail of the barium liquid bolus as they traversed the pharynx, UES, and subsphincteric area of the esophagus. The videofluoroscopic images were digitized by the computer image analysis system at a rate of one video field every 60th of a second. The video analysis software was used to mark the x-y coordinates of the center of the pellet and boundaries of the liquid barium bolus head and tail as the bolus moved through the pharynx and UES. The image analysis program in spreadsheet format stored the time-dependent coordinates. Thus, for any stored set of swallow sequence images, a time-dependent (x-y) mapping of bolus head and tail location was obtained. The bolus head and tail coordinates were numerically differentiated with respect to time to yield the velocity and differentiated twice to yield acceleration of the bolus head and tail. Along with the bolus kinematic data, we also determined, on fluoroscopy, the positions of the barium pellet and liquid barium bolus head and tail relative to the instant that the epiglottis appeared to make contact with the arytenoid cartilages at the posterior larynx (laryngeal vestibular closure) and relative to the instant of separation of the anterior and posterior walls of the pharyngoesophageal segment (UES opening). We determined the intraluminal pressure relative to the location of the barium pellet and liquid barium bolus head and tail. From the videofluoroscopic images, the position of the bolus relative to the manometric recording sites was determined throughout the swallow sequence. With use of the timing signal that coordinated the fluoroscopic images and manometric events for every video field, the pressure phenomenon proximal and distal to the bolus was determined for all barium pellet and barium liquid swallow sequences. For the purposes of the present study, we have used the term pressure gradient to refer to the spatial distribution of pressure from the most proximal to the most distal manometric recording site. The pressure between all adjacent sites will be evaluated to test the hypothesis (by ANOVA) that there are spatial differences in the measured absolute pressure among the manometric sites spanning the UES.
Results were analyzed for wave duration and nadir pressure and were compared with subatmospheric pressures recorded from the pharynx-UES area. Within-age group statistical analysis was done by ANOVA with repeated measures. Between-age group analysis was done by unpaired t-test and ANOVA. Values are means (SD) unless stated otherwise.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In addition, analysis of the pressure phenomenon within the pharynx, UES, and proximal esophagus showed, during each swallow, immediately before arrival of the pharyngeal peristaltic pressure wave at the most proximal manometric site, a transient pressure decline at all six transducer sites for dry swallow as well as liquid barium and barium pellet swallows.
Analysis of concurrent videofluoroscopic recordings of pellets and barium swallows showed that development of this pressure decline was concurrent with anterior displacement of the hyoid-larynx-cricoid complex and occurred in the hypopharynx, UES, and proximal esophageal recording sites located caudal to the luminal closure induced by the peristaltic wave. Distribution of this transient pressure decline through the pharyngoesophageal junction is shown in Figure 1. In 83% of solid pellet and 55% of liquid barium swallow for young subjects and 53% of solid pellet and 41% of liquid barium swallow for elderly subjects, the ambient pressure distal to the peristaltic pressure wave decreased to subatmospheric ("negative") pressure. The incidence of subatmospheric pressure distal to the peristaltic pressure wave during pellet swallows was significantly higher in young than in elderly subjects (
2 = 5.16, P = 0.023); however, no statistical differences in the incidence of negative pressure values during liquid bolus swallows were found between young and elderly subjects (
2 = 0.77, P = 0.38). The transsphincteric pressure behavior during pellet swallow in the elderly subjects was different from that in the young subjects, in that the nadir of pressure decline was significantly higher in the elderly than in the young subjects (Fig. 1).
|
|
Pellet kinematics and dynamic interrelation. Analysis of the concurrent manometric and videofluoroscopic recordings showed that, in both groups, the pellet traveled ahead of the peristaltic pressure wave. The distance between the pellet and the peristaltic front was 1.4 (SD 0.2) and 1.1 (SD 0.2) cm for the young and elderly subjects, respectively, when the peristaltic contraction wave reached the most proximal manometric site in the pharynx. The acceleration of the barium pellet was associated with incrementally decreasing pressure distal to the location of the pellet in the hypopharynx and across the UES. As the pellet passed each manometric recording site, the concurrent pressure at each site distal to it showed a progressive decline (Fig. 3).
|
The forces related to bolus tail kinematics were associated with the peristaltic pressure wave. Comparison of peristaltic pressure wave velocity, measured manometrically, and bolus tail speed, measured fluoroscopically, showed that the two phenomena were virtually identical: 11.0 (SD 0.3) and 10.9 (SD 0.3) cm/s, respectively, in the elderly subjects and 10.5 (SD 0.5) and 10.6 (SD 0.5) cm/s, respectively, in the young subjects. Also, analysis of the concurrent manometric and fluoroscopic recordings showed that the upstroke of the peristaltic pressure wave was always associated temporally and spatially with the tail of the barium bolus. In addition, analysis of concurrent manometric and fluoroscopic recordings identified three different zones in relation to the position of the bolus: 1) the peristaltic zone, located behind the bolus, 2) the bolus zone, occupied by the bolus, and 3) the prebolus zone, located ahead of the bolus. In the peristaltic zone, the lumen is occluded by muscular contraction and exhibited positive maximum pressure averaging 178 (SD 16) and 133 (SD 11) mmHg in the elderly and young subjects, respectively. The bolus zone is the unclosed luminal region that is occupied by the bolus. The prebolus zone, i.e., the region immediately distal to the position of the bolus (Fig. 4), exhibited a progressive decline in pressure across the pharyngoesophageal junction, for which subatmospheric pressures were commonly recorded as described above.
|
Comparison of the maximum laryngeal excursion between the successful and unsuccessful (entrapped pellet) swallows showed that the maximum laryngeal excursion was significantly less in the case of pellet entrapment (P < 0.001) than in cases of successful swallows in both groups (Figs. 5 and 6). Comparison of the transsphincteric pressure gradient between successful and unsuccessful (pellet entrapment) swallows showed that the pressure gradient observed in successful swallows was absent in unsuccessful swallows in both groups (Fig. 7).
|
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Two significant differences between the elderly and young subjects have been revealed in regard to solid and liquid bolus kinematics and dynamics: 1) Although in young individuals there are two zones of bolus acceleration in the pharynx, in the elderly the distal acceleration zone just above the UES is absent. 2) The downhill transsphincteric pressure gradient had a significantly higher nadir level in the elderly than in the young subjects. The presence of a decreasing pressure gradient throughout the pharyngoesophageal segment ahead of the swallowed bolus has been previously reported in young healthy individuals (8). Subsequent studies demonstrated the presence of similar gradients in intrabolus pressure as liquid boluses traverse this segment (13, 20). The differences observed in the present study add to the list of previously reported significant reduction in biomechanical events, such as anterior laryngeal excursion and the UES opening in the elderly.
Studies of chewing performance of food or synthetic material have shown that the diameters of the masticated particles range from 0.85 to 2.00 mm during optimal mastication (12). Studies of the physical characteristics of solid food during normal oral ingestion and mastication reported particle sizes of 51,500 µm for bread and 2.530 mm for spaghetti (6) and 30500 µm for bread and 0.86.2 mm for spaghetti (5). Studies of oropharyngeal sensitivity reported a correlation in the perception of 4- to 9-mm-diameter spheres and the size of normally chewed food particles (4). Furthermore, in studies of pill swallowing, particle diameters of 2.12.9 mm for freely masticated solid, nondissolving pills have been reported (1). Although the 2-mm pellet used in our study is seemingly small, it is within the range of values reported for solid particles swallowed during normal physiological mastication and deglutition.
Difficulty swallowing, especially a solid bolus and pills, is a common complaint of elderly individuals in whom no cerebrovascular accidents or neuromuscular diseases have been documented. Alterations found in this study of healthy elderly volunteers provide some explanation for the mechanisms that might contribute to the increased prevalence of these symptoms in this age group. When the pellet bolus failed to exit the pharynx, two simultaneous differences were observed (Fig. 5): 1) The anterior excursion of the larynx during these failed swallows was significantly less than that during successful swallows. 2) The downstream prebolus pressure gradient was absent and, in addition, exhibited a significantly higher nadir. It is reasonable to assume that the prebolus pressure gradient is induced by and reflects the rapid expansion of the pharyngoesophageal junction induced by the pulling contractions of the suprahyoid muscles responsible for anterior laryngeal movement and UES opening. If this assumption is true, our finding represents another important function of suprahyoid muscle contraction during deglutition, in that forceful contraction of these muscles induces rapid expansion of the UES lumen, resulting in a rapid decline in intraluminal UES pressure, which facilitates bolus transit through the pharyngoesophageal junction.
Earlier studies reported significant differences in several deglutitive biomechanical events between young and elderly subjects. The UES opening is significantly smaller in elderly than in young individuals (7, 18). Anterior hyoid and laryngeal excursion has reported to be shorter in elderly than in young individuals (7). Similarly, intrabolus hypopharyngeal pressure, an indicator of resistance to flow, has been reported to be higher in elderly than in young individuals, whereas the hypopharyngeal peristaltic wave amplitude and duration are accentuated in elderly compared with young individuals (7, 17, 21). If we consider the fact that dynamic forces of the deglutitive apparatus determine bolus kinematics, it can be postulated that the documented alterations of bolus kinematics in the elderly, reported in the present study, could be the consequence of changes in the dynamics of bolus flow induced by changes in the biomechanical deglutitive events in the elderly (see above).
Furthermore, hyoid and laryngeal displacement during deglutition are closely linked to tongue movement (11, 14), especially with regard to the efficient formation and handling of nonliquid boluses just before deglutition. Previous reports have shown age-related impairment of lingual function (10, 15). These changes could potentially contribute to the mechanisms of our finding of age effects on solid bolus kinematics. Better definition of the interrelation between alterations in lingual function and changes in bolus kinematics in elderly individuals warrants further investigation.
Our finding of two acceleration zones measured in young subjects corroborates findings of previous studies (8). These two zones include the region at the posterior tongue and the hypopharynx and were separated by a zone of deceleration at the level of the inverted epiglottis. Our finding of the proximal acceleration zone in the elderly suggests preservation of the mechanisms that contribute to the acceleration in this area. Conversely, the absence of the distal acceleration zone in the elderly suggests alteration in the mechanisms associated with development of this acceleration. These mechanisms may include the contractile function of the suprahyoid muscles involved in hyolaryngeal excursion and UES opening as well as the lingual and pharyngeal contributions to pressure generation across the hypopharynx and UES.
Our study findings also show that in the elderly, similar to previous reports in young volunteers (8), the kinematics of the solid particles are similar to those of the head of the liquid bolus, but both are significantly different from kinematics of the tail of the liquid bolus.
In addition, findings of the present study in the elderly are consistent with those of previous reports in young subjects of three different pressure zones in the hypopharynx and pharyngoesophageal axis: 1) the peristaltic pressure, which reflects the lumen-obliterating contraction of the musculature, 2) the intrabolus pressure, which reflects the inertia and resistance to the flow of the bolus, and 3) the pressure phenomenon in the region ahead of the bolus, which exhibits a downhill gradient across the segment induced by rapid expansion of the pharyngoesophageal junction.
Previous manofluorographic studies of elderly subjects swallowing liquid boluses have measured the velocity of the liquid bolus head traversing the oropharynx and UES (3). These studies reported bolus head velocities in the oropharynx and hypopharynx for young subjects similar to those reported in the present study; however, the findings of these studies in elderly subjects show similar oropharyngeal and hypopharyngeal bolus head velocities compared with young volunteers. The discrepancies between these previous reports and the present study may represent differences in experimental technique, catheter configuration and placement, and analysis methodology.
During the pharyngeal phase of swallowing, three of the four routes to the pharynx, i.e., the oral cavity, the nasopharynx, and the larynx, are sealed, while the fourth route, i.e., the UES, is open to remove the bolus. At the apogee of swallow, when the bolus reaches the hypopharyngeal opening of the UES, the development of a transsphincteric pressure gradient, which may facilitate the direction and entry of the bolus into the UES and proximal esophagus, occurs ahead of the bolus. Our observation in this study that pellet entrapment in the hypopharynx was accompanied by reduced anterior laryngeal excursion (Fig. 6) and the absence of a transsphincteric pressure gradient (Fig. 7), in contrast to the situation in the case of no bolus entrapment, supports this notion. It is conceivable that this transsphincteric pressure gradient is influenced by the phases of respiration and intrathoracic pressure; therefore, swallowing in end inspiration could potentially enhance the transsphincteric gradient and facilitate flow. This issue merits further studies, especially in terms of its potential application in dysphagic patients.
In summary, solid and liquid bolus kinematics are significantly altered among healthy elderly individuals compared with young individuals. These alterations include the absence of hypopharyngeal bolus acceleration and a significant increase in the transsphincteric pressure gradient.
| GRANTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. M. Felton, T. A. Gaige, T. G. Reese, V. J. Wedeen, and R. J. Gilbert Mechanical basis for lingual deformation during the propulsive phase of swallowing as determined by phase-contrast magnetic resonance imaging J Appl Physiol, July 1, 2007; 103(1): 255 - 265. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. K. Ghosh, J. E. Pandolfino, Q. Zhang, A. Jarosz, and P. J. Kahrilas Deglutitive upper esophageal sphincter relaxation: a study of 75 volunteer subjects using solid-state high-resolution manometry Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol, September 1, 2006; 291(3): G525 - G531. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Visit Other APS Journals Online |